Well, I’m confused with reviewing process after rejection. I’ve uploaded logo template and it was rejected with REVIEWER NR 1 . I said ok, she is right, it will look better if I’ll do what she said.Rejection reason was clearly stated (thx for it):
- 1. The gradient detracts from the design (btw, I liked the gradients :D)
- 2. The font is a bit too spaced to make the design balance
- 3. The drop shadow makes the design over complicated
I made all of the changes and reuploaded. Unfortunately this time another REVIEWER reject it with totaly different reason.
Rejection reason was:
This is an interesting concept, but the file here needs a little more work. The composition and layout needs a little more refinement. The elements are placed too closely together and it just looks a little too abstract.
I would like to reupload it and wait for the first reviewer to watch it as it seems like she would accept it as it is and now it could be like lottery to get accepted after another reviewer will look at it and finds some another reason, why he/she doesn’t like it…. Is it possible?
Below are preview images from 1st and 2nd rejection.
EDIT : dam forgot to choose Item Discussion category, pls move it there and srry….
Moved to Item Discussion.
When resubmitting item, did you mention the reviewer’s name who rejected it and did you also mention the improvements that you’ve made?
I think you should hand adjust the kerning of each letter in “socialconnect.” It just doesn’t look right to my eyes. Also, the contrast between “social” and “connect” could be greater.
second better than first one, dont give up mate, i have created 85 logo, only 25 was approved its little bit sad (about my story), but we are designers, and we love our work) Relax, take a breath, and try something to fix, and reupload this item. Your logo have a potencial! Good luck!