Could you send some examples of logos that were rejected? That could give us a better idea.
And yes: in the logo category anything goes, from rejection of great items to acceptance of rubbish.
And no: at Envato you won’t be helped with a hard rejection. Only soft rejections may get you some feedback.
My apologies I must have misinterpreted the original post.
I thought he wanted to purchase a vector here, and then use that vector to create a logo to sell here.
So basically I thought he wanted to resell another authors item by just making a few changes.
My apologies for the misunderstanding.
I agree, logo licence issues aare a pain in the neck.
In fact the entire logo market is a pain in the neck (no offence to logo authors, I am following a number of great logo authors here ) – I just think it’s a different market.
Frankly, I would find it incredibly stupid to create a logo with someone else’s clipart … or am I missing something here?
Certainly not a bad idea. I would imagine they will simply refer to a guide as to what is “good design” And if your item gets hard rejected it’s “bad design”, or simply not needed. If it gets soft rejected you will often find tips from the reviewer on how to improve your item.
The “Needed and un-needed items” list is also ancient. I wonder if it’s still relevant
What I would personally like to see even more is consistent guidelines I know both I and the reviewers will follow.
As per my thread here a few days ago: I still do not know whether I can include a vector logo in my stationery items. I’ve been told that I must rasterise it, yet every week I see items in thiscategory with vector logos included. So what’s the deal, can I can I or not?
Surely there must be other similar questions from other authors which are pretty easy to answer, and which are also pretty easy to convey to all reviewers. It would be good to have the same baseline for everyone.
I’m sure more authors will add to this thread with my suggestions.
For a few days now for some of my items when I click on the analytics I only get the page views/referrals for the last day. Anything before that is simply at zero for the current month, and nothing at all for any previous months.
I do know there have been visits, because I’ve made sales.
Has any of you experienced something like that? It happens on some of my items, on others it doesn’t.
Yes, I took a look at your portfolio. There are some nice work there.
I think it’s basically because many of your flyers have the same sort of layout: big badge as central piece, photo behind it, text below.
I do realise that you are not the only one who’s doing this. I’ve seen this in other portfolios too, and I always wondered why they keep admitting the same Style over and over from the same authors.
I assume this is why it got rejected with that message. But I do agree that this is lacking consistency because other authors do the same thing.
Maybe you could send a screenshot of your rejected item? That would help us see exactly what was meant.
If the badge you use over again is the main centrepiece of the flyer, then maybe using a different one would be a good idea.
@Nico – no, I never point the finger, so I never meant to say that your work lacked quality, on the contrary! I was speaking globally, conceptually
Agreed on consistency – or lack thereof.
Front page exposure will not generate any sales. It used to, but these days you are on the front page for about five minutes, then you’re gone again. A few years back an item could sometimes remain on the front page for a full day. These days it’s minutes.
What will generate sales are consistently producing quality items and thus building a loyal clientele.
Yes, even top authors get rejections. Keeps you on your toes!
This is a tricky one. The only item I ever had rejected were web buttons. At the same time I see some really poor ones out there, still being accepted this month!
I think of this category there is little consistency of what is accepted and what is rejected. In this case I would argue there’s probably simply not enough there. Many of the items I see accepted lately have many different variations of buttons.
I don’t think there is anything wrong with this item. It’s not badly designed, it’s nice and clean.. Probably just simply not enough there.
You could try making a UI kit out of it by adding numerous more elements. You could also try adding button variations.
But in that category, there is simply no guarantee. Pretty much the same as in business cards.
your portfolio is far too small to experience consistent sales. Most of us have ups and downs. I have a lot more items than you, and I still experienced this.
This has nothing to do with quality of your items. It happens to all of us.
This month for example my first two weeks have been fantastic, then the third week has been really poor.
Usually I hardly have any sales on weekends, this month my best day was a Saturday.
So you see it’s never totally consistent. You should however see some consistency at the end of the month. If you keep adding items at regular pace, then your volume of sales should also either remain stable or increased step-by-step on a monthly basis.