Hello need suggestion about my soft rejected logo. Here is the massage from reviewer-
“With simple shapes, the rendering has to be perfect with a considered use of proportion and geometry. The font needs to match the shape and the design must be balanced and aligned properly.
The buttons have to be different to PS as it’s a copyright design.”
Here is the preview-
I’ll update the buttons but confused about font and others. Thank you
as the isacfabian says,
I didn’t use Illustrator yet and actually I can’t. So is it okay that I save the logo as EPS in photoshop and included them in the zip. But I little confused about the text, will it remain editable or not?
What you guys think about that?
I know it’s a silly question. But really I want to know the difference. I saw that most of the popular or sold Logo templates are include vector EPS and AI file, less includes PSD .
I’m always make my logo in Photoshop. So my question is, Did Vector EPS and AI sells higher than PSD ? Or high demanding among buyers?
What you guys feels.
agree with the xstortionist, what he said.
But I think in my opinion Your client has wrong thinking or misunderstanding about the ENVATO .
About Plagiarism, envato always tries to make their marketplace as unique as possible. Reviewers will reject your file if it closely match with any existing item. There are huge files in here so sometime they also mistake. we have to know that they are also humans.
About weak quality, I didn’t see better quality graphic stuff in any other site yet, I’m using net about 3 years. It is a very big and increasing community. So when big number of people gather it is natural that all will not in same level. Some are experts and some are new, so the works of them also differ but we have a quality standard [which reviewers strictly follows] and that is much higher from others.
About Ridiculous forums, This is the best Forum in my opinion. ENVATO separated and maintained the forum very wel in my opinionl. We can post separate topic in separate category. Graphicriver, Item discussion, Item requests, site feedback, off topics, etc all are well organized. Some time mistakes happens it’s natural. If you need to read some suggestions and you search in off topic category, you will got nothing. In here all authors helps each other.
Hope you understand and didn’t take me wrong. You should tell your client about that. We are here and we know how it is. We are really great.
Okay, so I’ve to work on it more. Change the style and also font as well. Confused about other two designs, will work on them more.
What would I change in main typography? Font, size or style? I can’t find appropriate font for it.. can you guys give me some font suggestions. where did you get fonts? and are overall look okay without font?
Thanks a lot. really appreciate it
reviewer said – This logo is slightly too basic and doesn’t carry a strong enough concept to execute the idea. The concept needs some further refinement to make a stronger design The design needs further refinements to the layout and balance of the design.
Then I’ve worked on it and come up with this result – http://i1256.photobucket.com/albums/ii489/CSO-2012/preview.jpg
Need feedback before re-submit it.