Interesting topic guys/girls.
If I had to guess the reason they’re accepting a lot more themes now is probably because they’ve seriously re-vamped the pricing and will introduce a tiered system. Like a department store, you have your local store branded t-shirt at $9.99, Calvin Klein at $25 and Armani at $75. Not saying that’s what it will be like here, just a guess.
I’m hoping that’s what’s in the pipeline though. It’s what I would do anyway.
If you look at the WordPress.org themes, they have 1515 themes currently with close to 50 million downloads (granted, most of those numbers are just people re-downloading updates). Even if you count 20% of that number, it’s 10 million! I don’t think all the themes combined here have been sold a million times. So there’s still a lot of growth you guys can experience. Also, the WordPress.org themes, though lacking in design aesthetics, do make up for in technical ability and coding with WordPress standards (most of the time). Which is not always the case here. I’ve independently fixed a lot of things wrong with some of the top 20 themes being sold here for clients who have bought them and wanted customizations. It was painfully profitable.
Community and all that is great, but they’re a business. They’ve always been a business. Perhaps you feel the enthusiasm has been diminishing lately, I’m sure the higher ups are still very passionate about what they do. But, at the end of the day they still have numbers to crunch.
I’m not defending them, just offering a perspective which they don’t know how to relate to you guys without getting too involved in business speak. I’ve been selling my own stuff independently for quite some time now, so I can kinda relate to my presumption of their strategy (which, again, is just my mind thinking…nothing official).
Anyway, best of luck to all of you.

