I started a thread on this a while back…http://videohive.net/forums/thread/commenting/81394?page=1#683816
This is amazing!!
I really hope you get this sorted, and remember to send your professors a postcard. : )
There’s no way that i can accept that forcing the person who gave 1 star to give feedback, would have given me a fair feedback because psychology does not work that way. So the feedback had a 60% chance of being false anyway. The fact that I only got one star to me is good enough reason that I have a good theme, and I will only start to worry if it turns into a lot of one stars.
Two questions… firstly are you not bothered at all that potentially some complete moron downloaded your template, unzipped it and expected it to be online full of revenue creating ads and gaining more likes than Miley Cyrus’ butt cheeks and was upset when it did not happen so left you a 1 star review?
If they had left a bad rating and had to explain the reason for the review they would either have not left one (as they would have looked like an idiot) or had they, you would have been able to politely reply and explain what was needed to use your product. Remember, you might see the one 1 star review as reason to be happy but a customer might see it as one reason too many not to buy your template.
Secondly, what if you did start to receive a lot of one star reviews. What then? You have no way of contacting the customer, no way of knowing what is wrong with the template, and no way of reassuring those looking at your item to buy it that any potential bugs that past customers had experienced are now all sorted.
If you give service just because you don’t want a bad rating then it’s wrong and it’s not the fault of the feedback system.
One gives service because a proper coder supports the code they wrote no other reason. You should give excellent service even if there’s no rating system. That’s the minimum requirement of selling any product.Your faults an deficiencies will come out in the comments and support, if you cannot see it it’s again not the fault of the rating system.
This is kind of insulting…
I don’t give support just to get good ratings, I get it because I believe in what I have created and want to make sure each customer gets the most out of it.
I have some one star reviews but look at the comments and you will see not one piece of negative feedback. Someone didn’t like my template or had a problem with it and I have no idea what I can do to improve it so as to avoid future customers experiencing the same issue. That is how I want to support my customers.
I=f a actor plays in a movie, he must know that no matter how brilliant he plays his part, someone will say that he played badly.
In this example the reviewer would write what they didn’t like about aforementioned actor and that is all we are asking for as authors. A poor film review is meaningless without reason.
Are the rating system bad, or are you struggling to take criticism?
How can we take it badly if there is no criticism to take? 1 star by itself is not criticism, it is just evidence that someone didn’t like/had a problem with/couldn’t understand a certain aspect of the product. We just want to know what that is so it can be fixed.
Why don`t you all just get over it? The buying and rating process must be kept simple as possible. Beside, it`s my right as customer to rate as I want without having to explain anything, as long as I paid for a specific product. If the customers would have really wanted to explain the fact that made them to rate 1 star, they would have just posted a comment, the comments area it`s just one click away.
But is it not fair for an author to know why there product got a poor review? Especially if they are getting a lot of good feedback too?
Yes you have the right to rate a product as you wish but to just rate something 1 star because you want to without letting the author (or envato for that matter) know what bugs etc. passed the approval process is not going to help anyone. I am not suggesting you do that but there are a lot of threads out there of people who have been threatened with 1 star ratings for not bending over backwards and completely re-building items for free.
If a buyer rates the theme 1 star with feedback saying “Lack of support” we should be able to reply back to the feedback and defend ourselves on why this isn’t true or even apologize and provide a reason why there was a lack of support.
But since most of the potential buyers will only see the rating and won’t bear to read the explanations, the whole purpose of this is defeated.I think the best way of handling ratings would be to do exactly what YouTube did with their rating system. They had a 5-star rating system and ditched it for the like/dislike system and now you get percentages and clear view on how many people like and don’t like the item. In our case this would be the best-case scenario imo.
Disagree with this, if I was buying a template that had 4 5 star ratings and two 1 star reviews I would read the reviews by these unhappy customers. If these negative reviews had a reply from the author saying “sorry for lack of support , I was on holiday”, or “this customer contacted me saying they tried to open in itunes and got angry when I said they needed after effects” I would feel much more comfortable buying the template knowing that the error was not the author’s fault.